In science classes, when we offer this toolkit of baloney detection, as Carl Sagan described, students will be better able to question claims. They will be a better consumer, a more thoughtful citizen that can seek evidence for the claims of their potential electoral candidates, and a better navigator in the sea of media, including the Internet.
Skepticism is healthy. Knowing how much evidence and reason -- and not just words, authority and fancy speeches -- you personally need to believe a claim, is a gift we can give our students. To develop this level of questioning we should confront students with examples of pseudoscience, misrepresentations, and shoddy claims. The more students investigate claims in a classroom setting, the more privy they'll be to schemes and the better they'll be able to participate meaningfully in the scientific process.
This is especially true in science! Conspiracy theories are popular, they present just like real science on the internet, and they seem very convincing to students and the general public. In just the last few years people have told me about how the government caused massive tornados to stimulate the economy, that the moon landings never occurred, the government carried out 911, and that the Denver airport was built to prepare for the apocolypse. That is just the tip of the iceberg!
ReplyDelete