Showing posts with label Mod2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mod2. Show all posts

Sunday, October 19, 2014

Scholarly Articles and Google

One of the greatest injustices in the world is the fact that tax-payer funded scientific research gets published in scholarly journal articles that charge lots of money for a subscription to the journal or $30 for a download.

For a high school teacher, unequipped with libraries that have almost unlimited access, scientific research papers are hard to procure. I think for students to learn about real world science and the process of science, a peer-reviewed published article is key.

Think of all the models a journal article illustrate:
Proper citations.
Peer review.
Methodology.
Clear procedures.
Carefully crafted conlusions.

Without access to databases, a science teacher is left with only popular articles which may distort the value and significance of the findings or misrepresent the research. I loathe when I am reading a science blog citing a research paper without being able to freely download the paper. The research remains behind closed doors. Even if I am offered free access to the abstract, I am often left without knowledge if the paper is appropriate for students. I am not willing to gamble my money or my school's money to buy a research article.

What is a solution?
Google Scholar. Most articles are free. Try it out.

Wikipedia, or Why I Stopped Hating and Learned to Love the Internet

1994

I remember it like it was 18 years ago.

My father was convinced by a door-to-door salesman to buy a set of World Book Encyclopedias. How incredibly obsolete they are 18 years later. They sit on the bottom shelf, collecting dust -- Goodwill even refuses to accept old sets.

They are stagnant. If new material/technology arises, the salesman is not going to return to my father and make changes.
The books are limited. As a kid I thought my father just purchased the sum of the world's knowledge. Hardly. I think I looked up the Milwaukee Brewers and was angry to find that there was no entry.

When wikipedia first entered the scene, my teachers warned students that wikipedia is not a credible source. Now I'm a teacher, what do I think about wikipedia? I love it.

I recommend watching a ted talk by Jimmy Wales, the founder of wikipedia, about how wikipedia works. The process of running wikipedia probably involves more rigorous fact-checking than early encyclopedias.

So why do I like wikipedia?

  • Speed. Information is added with little delay. If a public figure dies, the wikipedia page is updated in real time.
  • Citation needed. Wikipedia is a great starting point on almost every topic. Because citations are needed, I have access to many sources listed at the bottom of the webpage. Its a diving board into the deepest pool of knowledge.
  • Simple English. If a page is too confusing, which happens when I search esoteric topics and when younger students are on wikipedia, there is Simple English wikipedia; same content, easier language.
  • Editable. If a magazine posts a false claim, it will be there forever. Maybe they'll apologize for a wrong fact in the next issue, but the original issue cannot be changed. A wrong fact that makes it onto wikipedia can be expunged from the record.
I wonder if my high school English teacher has changed his tune.


Extra: One of the problems of credibility, not exclusive to wikipedia, is exemplified by this comic. On the internet, once a thought is added and written into credible sites, that knowledge snowballs exponentially until someone takes the time to dig deeper.