Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Saturday, April 25, 2015

Open-access? Or private profit from taxpayer dollars?

God bless the Green Bay Packers. The team owners are the taxpayers of Wisconsin.

Other teams have owners that bully cities to fork out taxpayer dollars for stadiums where they can earn private profit. The Green Bay Packers avoid this abhorrent ethical quandary:

  • Should taxpayer dollars be spent for private gains?

Consider the exchange from page 12 of the Supreme Court Oral Argument of the 2013 case Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc.

  • "JUSTICE SCALIA: But you still haven't 18 answered her question. Why? Why would a company incur massive investment if it -- if it cannot patent?
    MR. HANSEN: Well, taxpayers paid for much of the investment in Myriad's work, but --
    JUSTICE SCALIA: You're still not answering the question."
Context: Myriad received public dollars for research; then the company placed a patent on a gene linked to breast cancer and charged a lot of money for the test. Myriad eventually lost the case, not because of the ethics of the taxpayer, but because they were not following patent protocol. DNA is unpatentable.

I feel that unless it is an issue of national security, taxpayer funded research results should not be hidden from the public; so I am fan of open source. If for no other reason, and educated and informed citizenry makes for a better democracy. When I heard about the death of Aaron Swartz after his prosecution for downloading and sharing academic articles I was appalled.

Open source was the solution but predatory journals that charge fees to the scientists take advantage of the system. In 2013, 120 journals had to retract gibberish papers. (You can try it yourself using a computer generator). Because open-access aren't relying on subscriptions, they do not necessarily need to be rigorously peer-reviewed.

So what is the future of open-access? How should we unbiasedly and fairly pay for quality control of open-access?