Showing posts with label textbooks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label textbooks. Show all posts

Sunday, April 26, 2015

Textbooks - Use Sparingly

Our 2002 middle school science textbooks are outdated; this is perfectly fine with me.

The internet is a free resource where I can find a plethora of information at my fingertips. The internet, is often better than a textbook because on the internet you can find information that is
  • generated by teachers
  • updated in real time
  • as detailed as you desire
  • visual stimulating. A quick video of an experiment is easier to understand than a diagram in a textbook.
Consider the example of the atomic model of the atom. If I were to rely solely on the content of my textbook, I would be missing epistemology of the development of historical models, missing the opportunity to engage students in the process of scientific inquiry.

From the book:

"1808 - Dalton Model: British chemist John Dalton published his New System of Chemical Philosophy, explaining that each element is made of small atoms and that different elements have atoms of different mass. Dalton imagines atoms as tiny, solid balls.

1897 - Thomson Model: British scientist J.J. Thomson proposed a new model. He suggested that an atom is a positively charged sphere with electrons embedded in it. His model could be described as looking like a muffin with berried scattered through it.

1911 - Rutherford Model: British physicist Ernest Rutherford concluded that the atom is mostly empty space. Electrons orbit randomly around a small positively charged nucleus." 
2002 Prentice Hall Science Explorer: Physical Science

No justification was given for the development of any of the atomic models. The 7th grade student has no access to the evidence for progressive models of the atoms. If avoid teaching the evidence for ideas, or not guiding students to ask for evidence, we are encouraging students to accept claims at face value -- this is antithetical to science!

So I took to the internet to spice things up. Naturally, I found information at all levels. But here are some sources I shared with my 7th grade students.

With the help of the internet, I hope my students have a better understanding of the nature of science and the need for theories to be based on observation and experimentation.