Showing posts with label theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label theory. Show all posts

Saturday, April 25, 2015

The Call for Scientific Rigor in Educational Research

At many schools, and my previous school, teaching to learning styles is purported on soapboxes as a key component to quality classroom instruction. Where is the evidence for that?

According to a recent opinion editorial in the New York Times citing a 2009 paper, the idea that instructors should teach to the learning styles of students isn't supported by the studies that took the effort to conduct randomized trials.

I think of all the hours of planning time centralized around the theory of Multiple Intelligence (and I regret calling MI a theory because it muddies the colloquial sense of theory with the scientific gold-standard of explanation that stands up to repeated observation and experimentation.) A critical analysis of Gardner's idea summarizes that, "in the end, Gardner’s theory is simply not all that helpful. For scientists,the theory of the mind is almost certainly incorrect."

Sometimes I feel that educational research throws around buzzwords and theories that are not founded in repeated experimentation. Teacher training programs should identify best-practice and test it repeatedly to deem its effectiveness, before it becomes a staple of professional development.

Much hinges on the ramifications.